8 Pumpkin Pie Recipes to Fall For

When it comes to Thanksgiving, pumpkin pie might be the most essential element there is. Sure, turkey is central to the feast, but vegetarian Thanksgiving is a thing. Pumpkin-free Thanksgiving? If that’s a thing, it’s a sad one about which we will speak no more.

Fun fact: Pumpkins grow on the ground and are easy to think of as vegetables, but they’ve got their seeds on the inside, which makes them fruit. (Even more fun fact: I learned this from the TV show Waffles + Mochi, which is ostensibly made for children but if you haven’t checked it out, just please do.) 

This dual nature means that pumpkin plays well with a wide range of flavors both sweet and savory. The dense flesh is versatile and blends well with fruit, spices, nuts, and chocolate to make a wide range of desserts. You can spice it, bake it, or even freeze it into an ice cream pie that will convert anyone who thinks they don’t care for pumpkin. Put it in a crust, leave it open like a tart, drizzle it with caramel, stud it with streusel…there’s almost no limit to what you can do with this fall gourd. 

You may think all pumpkin pies are the same, and if you’ve been relying on supermarket pastry (or the recipe on the back of a can of purée), that may be true. So break out of the average pie rut this year with one of the recipes below and fall in love with this Thanksgiving standby all over again. 

1 of 8Romulo Yanes

Pumpkin Ice Cream Gingersnap Pie

Making this crowd-pleaser couldn’t be easier—just stir together seasoned pumpkin pie filling and ice cream and spoon into a gingersnap crumb crust.

Recipe: Pumpkin Ice Cream Gingersnap Pie

2 of 8Annabelle Breakey

Apple Pumpkin Galette

Basically an open-face pie, this is a great dessert for pie-phobes to make because the crust is so easy to handle.

Recipe: Apple Pumpkin Galette

3 of 8Iain Bagwell

Kabocha Squash Crème Fraîche Pie

Feel free to swap in other squash in pastry chef Michelle McKenzie’s recipe: Sugar Pie comes out sweeter, and canned pumpkin is mellow-tasting, if less distinctive. Shauna Sever, an 18 Reasons instructor, suggested the spicy gingersnap layer. You’ll need a 9-in. deep-dish pie pan.

Recipe: Kabocha Squash Crème Fraîche Pie

4 of 8Annabelle Breakey

Pumpkin Brûlee Tart

This incredible fall pumpkin recipe is pumpkin pie meets crème brûlee, and worthy of your next dinner party.

Recipe: Pumpkin Brûlee Tart

5 of 8Leigh Beisch

Pumpkin Streusel Pie

Embellish a classic pumpkin pie with a streusel topping, then overlap pastry leaves around the edge and set a few on top for a festive presentation.

Recipe: Pumpkin Streusel Pie

6 of 8Annabelle Breakey

Pumpkin Caramel Ice Cream Pie

This irresistible pumpkin recipe features layers of pumpkin and vanilla ice cream topped with gooey caramel on a graham cracker crust.

Recipe: Pumpkin Caramel Ice Cream Pie

7 of 8Leo Gong

Pumpkin-Orange Mascarpone Pie

Jazz up the traditional Thanksgiving dessert with mascarpone, a hint of orange flavor, and a gingersnap crust.

Recipe: Pumpkin-Orange Mascarpone Pie

8 of 8Annabelle Breakey

Pumpkin-Orange Cheesecake with Chocolate Crust and Salted Caramel

For a fissure-free cheesecake, beat your filling just until it’s blended–no more. (Too much air in the mixture will make it deflate and then crack in the oven.)

Recipe: Pumpkin-Orange Cheesecake with Chocolate Crust and Salted Caramel

Search All of Sunset’s Recipes

Read the Current Issue Here!

Get one year of Sunset—and all kinds of bonuses—for just $24.95. Subscribe now!