Post Ranch Inn

Big Sur, CA

The hotel is a "crazy-expensive, one-of-a-kind experience," says our sleuth, but works hard for your money so you never feel nickeled-and-dimed. Ocean-facing rooms have an "edge-of-the-world quality" that no other Western hotel quite matches, and the sense of privacy is thrilling with a great yet "mostly invisible" staff and 25 buildings that melt into the hillside. Cliffside pools and private hiking trails let you revel in Big Sur's glorious landscape. And in addition to free yoga classes, snacks, drinks, and breakfast, you'll save on gas, seeing as "you'd be nuts to leave here during your stay." From $595 year-round; 39 rooms & suites; postranchinn.com

SCORE: 85