Best smoked salmon

Our three taste-test winners

A beautiful fillet of flaky, savory hot-smoked salmon makes any Sunday brunch special. Judging a field of 12 Western artisan brands on both presentation and deliciousness, we named three “big fish” in a recent tasting.

All three picks eschew new fresh-pouch technology, which calls for refrigeration only after opening, in favor of the old-fashioned, cold-shipped, into-the-fridge route. We include our favorite serving suggestions ― if you can resist the urge to devour the fish right out of the package.

Cap’n Mike’s Holy Smoke

Why: Tender, moist, and intensely smoky, Mike’s is the perfect melt-in-your-mouth fish. “I could live on this,” one taster raved.

The back story: There really is a Cap’n Mike: His name’s Mike Hiebert, and he’s been fishing Northern California’s Bodega Bay for 20 years.

Best with: Pasta with lemon, mint, and sour cream.

Info: Alderwood Smoked Salmon, $29 per lb.; Cap’n Mike’s Holy Smoke (707/585-2000)


Gerard & Dominique Seafoods

Why: Because it comes with a delicate honey glaze that’s as different as it is delicious. This fish is “firm, salty, and a bit sweet ― just what it should be.”

The back story: When Seattle-area restaurateurs Dominique Place and Gerard Parrap couldn’t find a smoked salmon they liked, they started experimenting.

Best with: Scrambled eggs and chives.

Info: Northwest Style Bruce Gore Smoked Wild Coho Salmon, $63 for two 1-lb. packs; Gerard & Dominique Seafoods (800/858-0449)


Pacific Northwest Best Fish Co.

Why: Because it’s like smoked salmon candy. The caramelized coating makes this a “perfectly balanced mix of salt, smoked, and sweet.”

The back story: Dan Evans’s company, in Ridgefield, WA, has been refining its brown sugar and soy brine for the past five years.

Best with: A slice of cucumber, or nothing at all.

Info: Smoked King Salmon, $18 per lb.; Pacific Northwest Best Fish Co. (877/769-2378)


More ways with smoked salmon


    1 of 1

    Most Popular

    1. 10 raised bed garden ideas

      Get instructions for the ultimate planting box for your veggies. Plus: More ideas for raised bed gardens
    2. 20 favorite perennial flowers
    3. 20 colorful plants for shade gardens
    4. 53 favorite backyard projects
    5. 24 Best Places to Live and Work 2014